Wednesday, November 07, 2007


And it feels official now. My first criticism from a Star Trek fan before the book has even come out. From 8of5 on the IDW boards:

. . . it's an outdated interpretation of that era, Spock being such an oddity may fit if only earlier TOS existed and Spock was the only alien in Starfleet we ever knew. But that stopped being the case a long time ago, later TOS and subsequent series established there is nothing odd about living along side aliens by the 23rd century. Canon (and even more so in non-canon) Trek now makes it clear Humans have had formal relations with the Vulcans for two centuries prior to the setting of this comic. And assuming Starfleet was formed on, or shortly after, the formation of the Federation there will be Vulcans there with close and regular contact with Humans throughout the hierarchy of Starfleet for at good century preceding. And frankly by that time there are far more alien aliens known to, and part of, the Federation than the Vulcans. Even if Spock was say the first Vulcan to go to Earth's Academy rather than studying at the Vulcan Science Academy, and even if it was uncommon for ships to feature mixed species crew, its still silly for a crew (from a more civilised accepting future Human race) to have such a problem with something that by then really isn't that odd. Incidentally the Early Voyages comics established a crewperson under Pike called Nano, who served on the Enterprise from before Spock had transferred aboard. His species, the Lirin, are actually not all that different to the Vulcans, the crew managed not to be a bunch of xenophobes towards him. Or if they ever were managed to grow up before the time Spock came along.


Blogger J. M. Beroy said...

Hello! I like your script and I liked a lot to draw it. With respect to the subject of the narration, I believe that the human nature is not going to change too much in the next years, since it has not changed really throughout history. I believe that always there will be problems like which you describe in comic.

11:09 AM  
Blogger James Patrick said...

Yeah, and your art was great too. We should both be proud under that deadline.

And I always looked at the societies in Star Trek as trying to be perfect, rather than being perfect. Where would be the conflict if they were perfect?

It was great working together.

8:21 AM  
Blogger J. M. Beroy said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

12:28 PM  
Blogger J. M. Beroy said...

Yeah, thanks. There is another review, that surely you liked to read, here:

Sorry, you must cut & paste the link.

12:31 PM  

Post a Comment

<< Home